St. Augustine Contested Divorce Lawyer

Defending Your Rights in Complex Divorce Cases

Divorce is never easy, but when it becomes contested, it’s more than just a legal process—it’s a battle for your future. Disagreements over child custody, child support, or alimony can quickly turn a challenging situation into a high-stakes conflict. In these moments, you need a trusted legal advocate who understands what’s at stake and is prepared to fight for the outcome you deserve.

At Leonard Legal, we bring clarity and confidence to the contested divorce process. With years of experience representing clients in St. Augustine and throughout St. Johns County, we provide strategic guidance, unwavering advocacy, and personalized solutions tailored to your goals.

What is a Contested Divorce?

A contested divorce occurs when spouses cannot agree on one or more critical issues in their separation. These disputes often require negotiation, mediation, or even court intervention to resolve. Common areas of conflict include:

Custody and Parenting Plans

Who will your children live with? How will parenting time be divided? Florida courts prioritize the best interests of the child, focusing on factors like emotional stability, parental involvement, and the child’s overall well-being.

Division of Property

Florida’s equitable distribution laws require marital property to be divided fairly, not necessarily equally. Disputes often arise over high-value assets like homes, businesses, or retirement accounts. Leonard Legal ensures every asset is accounted for and properly valued.

Spousal Support (Alimony)

One spouse may seek financial support after the divorce, while the other disputes its necessity or amount. 

Courts evaluate factors like income disparity, the marriage’s length, and each spouse’s future earning potential.

Child Support

Even with clear guidelines, disagreements over income, expenses, or time-sharing schedules can complicate child support calculations.

At Leonard Legal, we handle these challenges with a strategic, detail-oriented approach, always prioritizing your best interests.

Contested vs. Uncontested Divorce: What’s the Difference?

Not all divorces follow the same path. While some couples can amicably agree on all key issues, others face disputes that require more time, negotiation, and legal intervention. Understanding the difference between contested and uncontested divorces can help you determine what to expect and how to proceed.

Uncontested Divorce

An uncontested divorce occurs when both spouses agree on all major aspects of their separation, including:

  • Division of property and debts
  • Child custody and time-sharing arrangements
  • Child support
  • Alimony (if applicable)

These divorces are typically faster, less expensive, and less stressful because there’s no need for court intervention. Many uncontested divorces are resolved through mediation or direct negotiations between the parties.

Contested Divorce

A contested divorce happens when spouses cannot agree on one or more key issues. These disputes often involve:

  • Custody and parenting arrangements
  • Division of significant assets or debts
  • Disagreements over spousal or child support

Contested divorces require more time and resources to resolve, often involving mediation, discovery, and, in some cases, a trial. While more complex, contested divorces ensure that critical matters are addressed with legal precision and fairness.

Why Does It Matter?

Whether your divorce is contested or uncontested will shape your experience and the legal steps required. If you’re unsure which category your case falls into, we can help you evaluate your situation and recommend the best course of action.

Speak With Our St. Augustine Divorce Family Lawyer

How the Contested Divorce Process Works in Florida

Navigating a contested divorce requires clarity and preparation. Here’s how we guide you through the process in St. Augustine:

Step 1: Filing and Response

Your contested divorce begins when one spouse files a petition for dissolution of marriage, outlining unresolved issues. The other spouse must formally respond, either agreeing or contesting the terms.

Step 2: Discovery

During discovery, both parties exchange financial records, property details, and other key documents. Transparency is essential for fair outcomes, especially in cases involving complex assets.

Step 3: Mediation

Florida requires mediation before trial. This is a chance to resolve disputes with the help of a neutral mediator. While mediation often leads to agreements, we ensure your priorities are not compromised during the process.

Step 4: Trial

If disputes remain unresolved, the case proceeds to trial. A judge reviews evidence, hears arguments, and makes final decisions on issues like custody, alimony, and property division. At Leonard Legal, we prepare every case meticulously, ensuring your voice is heard in court.

Why Choose Leonard Legal for St. Augustine Contested Divorce Litigation?

  • Proven Results

Successfully resolved high-stakes disputes involving child custody, business ownership, and significant assets.

  • Local Knowledge

Extensive experience with St. Johns County courts, judges, and Florida divorce laws.

  • Client-Centered Approach

We tailor every strategy to meet your unique goals and needs.

  • Unwavering Advocacy

Whether in mediation or the courtroom, we fight to secure the best outcome for you.

Preparing for a Contested Divorce: Steps and Considerations

When facing a contested divorce, preparation is key. A contested divorce can be emotionally draining and legally complex, but taking the right steps early can set the foundation for a smoother process and a stronger outcome. Here’s how to prepare effectively:

1. Organize Your Financial Records

One of the most critical steps in a contested divorce is gathering and organizing your financial documents. This includes:

  • Bank statements
  • Tax returns (at least the last three years)
  • Pay stubs or proof of income
  • Property deeds and appraisals
  • Retirement account statements
  • Loan and credit card statements

Florida’s equitable distribution laws require transparency in financial matters, and thorough documentation ensures that all assets and debts are properly evaluated.

2. Understand Your Rights and Obligations

Florida has specific laws regarding contested divorces, including requirements for time-sharing with children, spousal support, and division of assets. Consulting a qualified divorce attorney early in the process can help you:

  • Learn what you’re entitled to under Florida law.
  • Understand the criteria for determining child custody and support.
  • Clarify how marital and non-marital property will be treated.

3. Prioritize Your Goals

Divorce involves many moving parts. Take time to identify what’s most important to you:

  • Is securing primary custody of your children your top priority?
  • Do you want to retain ownership of specific assets, such as the family home?
  • Are you seeking or opposing spousal support?

Your attorney can use this clarity to create a legal strategy tailored to your goals.

4. Prepare for Emotional Challenges

Divorce isn’t just a legal process—it’s an emotional one. Surround yourself with a strong support system, whether it’s trusted friends, family, or a therapist. Preparing emotionally allows you to approach negotiations and court proceedings with a clear head.

5. Keep Communication Professional

Contentious divorces often involve heightened emotions. Avoid escalating conflicts by keeping communication with your spouse professional and focused on resolving key issues. If direct communication proves difficult, let your attorney handle discussions on your behalf.

6. Work with an Experienced Divorce Attorney

An experienced St. Augustine contested divorce Attorney is your strongest ally in this process. From gathering evidence to representing you in mediation or court, your attorney ensures that your rights are protected at every stage.

Serving St. Augustine and Surrounding Communities

At Leonard Legal, we’re proud to provide trusted family law representation to the St. Augustine community and beyond. Navigating a contested divorce can feel overwhelming, but having a legal team that understands the unique dynamics of St. Johns County ensures you’re fully supported every step of the way.

From the historic charm of Lincolnville to the serene communities in St. Augustine Beach and Palencia, we’ve helped countless clients across St. Augustine protect their rights and secure favorable outcomes. Our familiarity with St. Johns County courts, local judges, and Florida’s family law procedures gives us a distinct advantage when crafting strategies specifically tailored to your case.

Take Control of Your Contested Divorce Today

When your divorce becomes contested, every decision matters. At Leonard Legal, we provide the clarity, focus, and determined advocacy you need to protect your rights and achieve a resolution that works for you.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation with a trusted St. Augustine contested divorce attorney. Together, we’ll build a strategy that secures your future.

FAQs About Contested Divorce

  • How much does a contested divorce cost in Florida?
    The cost of a contested divorce depends on the complexity of your case. Factors like disputes over custody, property, or alimony, as well as court and attorney fees, can affect the total expense.
  • What is the difference between contested and uncontested divorce?
    A contested divorce involves unresolved disputes that require negotiation or court intervention, while an uncontested divorce is resolved amicably with mutual agreements on all key issues.
  • How long does a contested divorce take in St. Augustine?
    Timelines vary depending on case complexity. Contested divorces can take several months to over a year, particularly if the case goes to trial.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Call us with any questions!


(904) 392-4573