Contested Divorce Attorney St. Augustine, FL

Contested Divorce in Florida: When Negotiation Fails, Litigation Wins

---

A contested divorce means the parties cannot agree on one or more critical issues: property division, child custody, alimony, child support, or debt allocation. When negotiation fails, the case must be resolved through litigation — and litigation is where preparation, strategy, and courtroom skill determine the outcome.

Christine Leonard is a trial-tested family law attorney who thrives in contested divorce cases. She does not treat litigation as a last resort — she treats it as a strategic tool. Every contested case is prepared as if it is going to trial from day one. That level of preparation is what produces favorable settlements at mediation and courtroom victories when settlement is not possible.

When to Expect a Contested Divorce

---

Not every divorce starts as contested, and not every contested divorce ends in trial. But certain situations make litigation more likely:

Custody disputes. When both parents want primary custody or cannot agree on a timesharing schedule, the court must decide what is in the best interest of the children.

Hidden assets or financial deception. When one spouse suspects the other is concealing income, hiding assets, or misrepresenting financial information, discovery and forensic investigation are necessary to uncover the truth.

Alimony disagreements. Disputes over whether alimony should be awarded, the amount, the type (bridge-the-gap, rehabilitative, durational), and the duration often require judicial intervention.

Complex property division. Cases involving businesses, professional practices, stock options, retirement accounts, real estate portfolios, or other complex assets often require expert valuation and judicial determination. See our high-asset divorce page for more information.

Domestic violence or substance abuse. When safety concerns exist, contested litigation may be necessary to protect you and your children. Christine also handles restraining orders and injunctions when immediate protection is needed.

Uncooperative spouse. When one spouse refuses to participate in the process, delays proceedings, or acts in bad faith, aggressive litigation is the only path forward.

The Contested Divorce Timeline

---

A contested divorce in Florida typically takes 6 months to over a year. The timeline depends on the complexity of the issues, the cooperation of the parties, and the court’s schedule. Here is the general process:

Filing and Service (Weeks 1–4). The Petition for Dissolution of Marriage is filed with the circuit court. The respondent is served and has 20 days to file a response. Christine files the petition strategically, often seeking temporary relief (temporary custody, temporary support, exclusive use of the home) at the time of filing.

Temporary Relief Hearing (Weeks 2–6). In many contested cases, the court holds a temporary relief hearing to establish interim arrangements for custody, support, and use of marital assets while the case is pending. These early hearings can set the tone for the entire case.

Discovery (Months 2–6). Discovery is the most critical phase of a contested divorce. Both parties exchange financial information, documents, and sworn testimony. Christine uses every discovery tool aggressively to build your case.

Mediation (Months 4–8). Florida courts require mediation before trial. Mediation is a structured negotiation session with a neutral mediator. Many contested cases settle at mediation — but only when both sides know the other is prepared to go to trial.

Trial Preparation (Months 6–10). If mediation does not fully resolve the case, Christine prepares for trial: organizing exhibits, preparing witnesses, drafting motions in limine, and building a compelling presentation for the judge.

Trial (Months 8–12+). At trial, the judge hears testimony, reviews evidence, and makes final decisions on all disputed issues. Christine presents your case with precision, cross-examines the opposing party and their witnesses, and advocates relentlessly for your interests.

The Discovery Process: Uncovering the Truth

---

Discovery is where contested divorces are won or lost. It is the legal process through which both parties exchange information and evidence. Christine Leonard uses discovery aggressively to uncover hidden assets, establish true income, document financial misconduct, and build an overwhelming case for trial or mediation.

Interrogatories. Written questions that the other party must answer under oath. Christine drafts targeted interrogatories designed to pin down the other side on critical financial and custody issues.

Requests for Production. Demands for documents including bank statements, tax returns, pay stubs, business records, credit card statements, loan applications, and real estate records. Christine knows where to look — and what to look for.

Depositions. Sworn testimony taken under oath before trial. Depositions allow Christine to question the opposing party and key witnesses, lock them into testimony, expose inconsistencies, and gather critical evidence for trial. Christine’s deposition skills are a significant strategic advantage.

Subpoenas. Court orders requiring third parties (employers, banks, financial institutions) to produce documents or testify. Subpoenas are essential when one party is not forthcoming with financial information.

Requests for Admissions. Written requests asking the other party to admit or deny specific facts. Strategic use of admissions can narrow the issues for trial and establish critical facts without the need for additional proof.

Mediation: Negotiating from Strength

---

Florida requires mediation in most contested divorce cases. Mediation is not a sign of weakness — it is an opportunity to resolve your case on your terms rather than leaving the decision to a judge. The key to successful mediation is preparation. When the other side knows you are fully prepared for trial, they are far more likely to negotiate a reasonable settlement.

Christine Leonard enters every mediation armed with complete financial analysis, a thorough understanding of the legal issues, and a clear strategy. She knows what the case is worth. She knows what the judge is likely to do at trial. And she uses that knowledge to negotiate from a position of strength.

Trial Preparation: No Shortcuts

---

When mediation does not resolve the case, you need an attorney who is genuinely prepared to try the case. Many attorneys talk about going to trial but have rarely done it. Christine Leonard has tried contested divorce cases across Northeast Florida courtrooms. She knows how to present evidence, examine witnesses, make legal arguments, and advocate before a judge.

Trial preparation at Leonard Legal includes comprehensive exhibit organization and presentation, witness preparation and practice direct examination, development of cross-examination strategies, financial analysis and summary exhibits, motions in limine to exclude prejudicial evidence, and a detailed trial strategy tailored to the specific judge assigned to your case.

Cost Factors in a Contested Divorce

---

Contested divorces cost more than uncontested divorces because they require more attorney time, expert involvement, and court resources. The major cost factors include:

Discovery and depositions. Gathering and analyzing financial information is time-intensive, and depositions involve additional preparation and court reporter fees.

Expert witnesses. Forensic accountants, business valuators, custody evaluators, and real estate appraisers may be necessary to establish values and support your position.

Mediation. Mediator fees and additional attorney preparation time.

Trial preparation and trial. Preparing for and conducting a trial is the most time-intensive part of a contested divorce.

Duration of the case. The longer a contested case takes, the more it costs. Christine Leonard works to resolve cases efficiently without sacrificing thoroughness.

Florida courts have the authority to order one spouse to contribute to the other’s attorney’s fees to ensure both parties have access to competent legal representation. Christine Leonard pursues fee awards when appropriate to help her clients access the legal resources they need.

Related Practice Areas